HISTORY OF THE DEATH PENALTY IN UKRAINE: CAUSES, STAGES AND INFLUENCE ON PUBLIC AWARENESS

Abstract. The purpose of the study is to reveal the historical reasons for the emergence and distribution of death penalty as well as the attitude of Ukrainians to this type of punishment. Particular attention is paid to the attitude of contemporary traditional ideological currents to the death penalty in Ukraine. The research methodology is based on the principles of historicism, continuity and objectivity. The interdisciplinary nature of the study led to the use of a range of general scientific, philosophical and special historical methods, among which we distinguish the following: historical method, comparative method, document analysis, and others.

The scientific novelty of the study lies in the social challenges Ukraine is currently facing, based on which we discuss the need to restore the death penalty. The historical retrospective and evolution of the assertion of the death penalty from ancient times to the present day has shown that the death penalty is not traditional. As a rule, its establishment on the territory of Ukraine is associated with the presence of the territory of our country within other states in a particular historical period, as well as subjective and objective conditions for the development of national liberation movements in the early and mid-twentieth century. Although not an inherent punishment for Ukrainians, the death penalty has a significant impact on the public awareness, as well as the processes of state formation. The formal and declarative nature of this type of punishment in the Old Rus state was replaced by active application in the Polish-Lithuanian era. This in turn influenced the adoption of the death penalty for war crimes among the Cossacks. The most ambiguous period in Ukrainian history and the use of the death penalty is the twentieth century, when the amnesty and renunciation of executions proclaimed by the Third Universal of the Central Rada changed to the use of the death penalty for war crimes during the Hetmanate, Directory and Western Ukraine. For Soviet totalitarianism, the death penalty was not so much a method of punishment as an instrument of asserting power.

Under conditions of independence, Ukraine has evolved from a country with one of the highest rates of the death penalty to its abolition. In our opinion, the debates in society and politics evidence the poor legal culture and historical memory, which actually need to be corrected, e.g. through scientific research.

If we try to define the role of the death penalty in historical retrospect, it was not just the factor of realization of a specific legal or ideological worldview, but also a measure of the spread of democratic and humanistic ideals and values. Attitude to the death penalty is a measure of “maturity of society”. As an object of repressive policy of the Soviet government, Ukrainians should become the main opponents of the death penalty as a punishment for crime in the 21st century, as Ukraine has always sought European standards of humanity and treatment of convicts.

References

45 % of Ukrainians want to return the death penalty, https://life.pravda.com.ua/society/2011/07/14/81714/. (in Ukrainian).
80 % of Ukrainians support the death penalty, https://tsn.ua/ukrayina/80-ukrayintsiv-pidtrimuyut-smertnu-karu.html. (in Ukrainian).
Almost half of Ukrainians want to return the death penalty, https://tsn.ua/ukrayina/maizhe-polovina-ukrayintsiv-hoche-povernuti-smertnu-karu.html. (in Ukrainian).
Bailey, V. (2000). The Death Penalty in British History. Punishment & Society, 2(1), 106-113. https://doi.org/10.1177/14624740022227881.
Barry, K. (2019). The Death Penalty and the Fundamental Right to Life, 60 B.C.L. Rev. 1545, https://lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu/bclr/vol60/iss6/3.
Baumgartner, F., De Boef, S., & Boydstun, A. Тhe Decline of the Death Penalty and the Discovery of Innocence. Cambridge University Press, https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511790638.
Beha, V. Lyashko promises to return the death penalty: he says he will put the issue to a referendum, https://hromadske.ua/posts/lyashko-obicyaye-povernuti-smertnu-karu-kazhe-sho-vinese-ce-pitannya-na-referendum. (in Ukrainian).
Burlakova, V. Even its supporters consider the death penalty inexpedient in Ukraine, https://tyzhden.ua/Society/46522. (in Ukrainian).
Didenko, A. Shooters, https://antydot.info/authors/rozstrilnyky/. (in Ukrainian).
Great Ukrainian legal encyclopedia: in 20 volumes. Kharkiv, Pravo, 2016. (in Ukrainian).
III Universal of the Ukrainian Central Council, http://gska2.rada.gov.ua/site/const/universal-3.html. (in Ukrainian).
Johnson, D. (2019). A Factful Perspective on Capital Punishment. Journal of Human Rights Practice, 11(2), 334-345, https://doi.org/10.1093/jhuman/huz018.
Khudoba, N. (2009). Austrian Code of Criminal Procedure of 1873 and its application in Galicia. Law Forum, 2, 417-422. (in Ukrainian).
Kukhta, B. (1994). Lecture text: Head assistant. From the history of Ukrainian politician thught. Kyiv, Heneza. (in Ukrainian).
Less than 40 % of Ukrainians are in favor of restoring the death penalty, https://dt.ua/UKRAINE/menshe-40-ukrayinciv-vistupayut-za-vidnovlennya-smertnoyi-kari-246713_.html. (in Ukrainian).
Lyskov, D. (2017). Stalinist repression. “Black myths” and facts, http://www.e-reading.mobi/bookreader.php/127609/Lyskov_-_Stalinskie_repressii._Velikaya_lozhʼ_XX_veka.html. (in Russian).
Misinkevych, L. (2013). Legislative bases of repressive policy of the Soviet power in Ukraine in the 20-30s of the XX century. University scientific notes, 1(45), 5-14. (in Ukrainian).
Nikolskyi, V. (2003). Repressive activity of the state security bodies of the USSR in Ukraine (late 1920s – 1950s). Historical and statistical research. Donetsk: publishing house of DonNU. (in Ukrainian).
Ordway, D.-M. (2019). Capital punishment and death row inmates: A research roundup. The Journalistʼs Resource, https://journalistsresource.org/criminal-justice/capital-punishment-death-row-research/?fbclid=IwAR1j7gG6bcE4opFrScDjDuhkAt-7MF1WBrWBz6CgumIIJlk1t4Ig-fMdDhg.
Panonko, I., & Strus, V. (2010). Crimes and punishments of the Cossack era. Scientific notes of Lviv University of Business and Law, 5, 158-163. (in Ukrainian).
Pasternak, L. The history of the death penalty in Russia: from Kievan Rus to the present, https://tjournal.ru/stories/124683-istoriya-smertnoy-kazni-v-rossii-ot-kievskoy-rusi-do-sovremennosti. (in Ukrainian).
Podkur, R. (2012). Formation of operational accounting of “counter-revolutionary elements” in the 1920s – 1939. Political repressions in the Ukrainian SSR 1937-1938: research reflections and interpretations. To the 75th anniversary of the “Great Terror” in the USSR: materials of the All-Ukrainian scientific conference. Kyiv, Institute of History of Ukraine NAN of Ukraine, 29-42. (in Ukrainian).
Political repressions of the 1920s and 1980s and problems of forming national memory, https://www.istpravda.com.ua/research/50db659307b77/. (in Ukrainian).
Recommendation no. 1246 (1994) of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe “On the abolition of the death penalty”, https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/994_158. (in Ukrainian).
Rules of the judiciary in the OUN. HDA SBU, http://avr.org.ua/viewDoc/6511. (in Ukrainian).
Shapoval, Yu. (2013). Ukraine in the days of the “Great Terror”: stages, features, consequences. Political repressions in the Ukrainian SSR 1937–1938: research reflections and interpretations. To the 75th anniversary of the “Great Terror” in the USSR. Kyiv, Institute of History of Ukraine, 128-163. (in Ukrainian).
Slyvka, S. (1996). The use of M. Drahomanovʼs legacy in modern legal education. Drahomanivʼs collection “Free Union” and modern Ukrainian constitutionalism. Lviv, Svit. (in Ukrainian).
Taranenko, M., & Kolomiiets, T. (2018). Genesis of the death penalty in Ukraine. National Legal Journal: Theory and Practice, 7(2), 31, 89-92.
Terletska, I. (2010). State terror in the USSR-USSR period of Stalinism in the domestic historiography of the early XXI century. From the archives of VUCHK-GPU-NKVD-KGB, 403-417. (in Ukrainian).
Terletska, I. (2011). The essence of Stalinism: historiographical understanding in modern Ukraine and Russia. Ukraine of the twentieth century: culture, ideology, politics, 16, 232-248. (in Ukrainian).
True Russian, http://litopys.org.ua/yushkov/yu03.htm.
Vasyliev, V. (2007). Features of repression in the governing structures of the USSR during the “great terror” (1937 – 1938). Kyiv, Institute of History of Ukraine NAN of Ukraine, 34, 177-197. (in Ukrainian).
Viedienieiev, D., & Bystrukhin, H. (2006). Sword and trident. Intelligence and counterintelligence of the Ukrainian nationalist movement and the UPA. 1920-1945. Kyiv, Heneza. 408 p. (in Ukrainian).
Yatsyshyn, M. (2015). The Institute of the Death Penalty in Ukraine: the international legal aspect of (non) application in 2015. In Criminal and executive policy of Ukraine and the European Union: development and integration. Kyiv, 80-83. (in Ukrainian).